A recent article from technology and advertising blog PSFK asks whether or not retail-focused smartphone applications make self-service solutions redundant. Even though the piece makes positive mention of Microsoft Surface and Intel’s intelligent digital signage proof of concept, it lists six reasons why retailers should exclusively focus on mobile development:

1. The phone is personal. It already knows who you are and can access what you like and even your purchase preferences like clothing sizes. With an interactive display you often have to start from the beginning.

2. The phone is social. The phone knows who your friends are and allows information before and after purchase to be shared between you and your peers. Sure, interactive displays can be connected to social media but are you really going to put your password to Facebook into an interactive display in a store that you visit once a month?

3. The phone is touchable. Would you rather tap away at the screen on the phone only you use or would you want to touch the smudged screen of the chain-store retailer where thousands of people pass through each day?

4. The phone is consumer-powerful. The phone keeps the power in the hands of the consumer while the interactive display offers the controlled world of the retailer. The interactive display doesn’t provide access to the world of group buying sites, deal services or comparative pricing apps.

5. Because a retailer can doesn’t mean they should. Just because WalMart stores have TVs throughout with advertisements running, it doesn’t mean that this service must be replicated across all retailers. Stores want to program specific environments that create subtle experiences that drive sales. A TV blasting ads – even if it’s interactive – might actually be a turn off for shpppers in many instances.

6. The phone is becoming sensitive. Technology is evolving to allow the phone to notice RFID tags and other ‘internet of things’ technology.

The above points are valid, but they look at the retail sector from a singular perspective. Smartphones are becoming an increasingly integral component in how we shop. They are not, however, the end all and be all of the consumer shopping experience. Just as the functionality of cellphones are growing more advanced so too are interactive digital displays. Retailers are right to focus significant energy on developing applications for mobile phones, but they must also devote resources to alternative in-store communications channels. Mobile is great, so too is digital signage.

What were once little more than computer stations in retail stores are evolving into immersive multi-touch gateways. Interactive video walls and intelligent self-service solutions are beginning to be integrated seamlessly into store environments. Their flexibility begets their utility. They function as integral parts of a store’s atmosphere. They can exist as omniscient sales associates, multi-user entertainment systems, or large-scale online catalogs.

Mobile phones and interactive digital signage should not be looked at as being mutually exclusive at retail. One doesn’t diminish the other. In reality, when they are positioned to enhance each other, consumers reap the greatest benefit. As I detailed in an earlier post, mobile applications and digital signage are allies, NOT adversaries. Whereas the mobile channel is geared around one-to-one interactions, digital displays at retail can be used to extend the engagement to a broad segment of consumers.

Mobile Applications and Digital Signage are Allies, NOT Adversaries

An in-store digital signage network is a one-to-many communication platform, yet still has the potential to foster a deeper connection than a one-to-one mobile interaction. Such is the nature of advertising when the medium is part of the message. It doesn’t mean that one platform, mobile or digital signage, is better than the other. It just illustrates that they offer alternate means of achieving the same goal: Lead Customer X to Purchase Brand A.

Rather than looking at the two platforms as adversaries, one harnesses each technology’s full value when pairing them as allies. Two arrows are always better than one. And, when one medium can increase the impact of another – use them together.

There are times when a brand may be better suited to use mobile instead of digital signage, and vice versa. But, in reality, given the fragmented nature of today’s media environment, its best to develop content for multiple platforms and target your message to reach consumers across various outlets.

Integrating Mobile and Digital Signage: Opportunities Abound

When given the choice of viewing content solely on a smartphone or interacting with the same content on a massive multi-touch display, which would you choose? I would go for the interactive digital signage, selecting the option that extends the boundaries of the user experience. What can be considered more exciting than selecting one option or the other is alternating between the two. Using a mobile phone to interact with a digital screen can create a unique experience that draws in multiple users and builds significant brand awareness (SEE: Locamoda, MegaPhone, Snaptell, Akoo)

Thanks to the portability of content, and innovations in the realm of cross-platform communication, shoppers can move between mobile applications and digital signage without skipping a beat. Each platform can function as a unique retail touchpoint, whereby each shopper has the ability to choose his own digital path though a store.
You might also like:

It would seem obvious that replacing a static sign with a digital screen, or adding a screen to an environment, would automatically create more awareness for whatever was being communicated. It’s easy to see that putting really great video (herein generally referred to as “content”) on an HDTV that someone wants to buy is a foregone conclusion. But that is not the case. In situations where the shopper is buying a staple, like shampoo or toothpaste or milk, the shopper is so focused on the mission at hand that almost all signage, static and digital alike, is ignored. The potential to miss the audience can be frustrating to a network operator that has spent enormous amounts of money to put in a network and wants to see a return on the investment.

The ultimate goal of digital signage is to change behaviors. It could be to navigate through an environment, or learn more about a product, or catch up on the latest news. But digital signage alone does not allow the operator to be better at communicating.

You need terrific content.

The ability to engage a viewer with outstanding visual content is not easily accomplished. The awareness and respect for content is increasing because providers continue to learn about the medium. The common battle cry of “It’s Not TV!” runs through the industry. It isn’t TV in the traditional sense of what we sit down and watch in our homes each night. But it is a screen designed to communicate, and the understanding of how to communicate is evolving as fast as the industry itself. It is TV, just a different kind of TV.

In the past, the novelty of a screen in a store or elevator or subway was enough to allow the network operator the freedom to simply hang a screen and turn it on. Now we are seeing screens treated as vital elements of design, being built into the physical structures. This completes the experience for the end-user and the audience. The screens and content look like it was made for the store, rather than just added on at a later stage in the environment’s evolution. Venues are constantly looking for advantages over their competitors, but brand logos, colors, and store layout can only go so far. Compelling, relevant content can give one environment over another by bringing the environment to life.

As much as good content has the ability to engage a viewer, bad content can detract a viewer just as fast.

High quality, relevant, and compelling content is the most important feature to digital signage in any application. It is the reason you’re adding the screens. It can connect you with viewers in ways never before achieved through the traditional methods of communication. Whether you are a brand, or a product, or a service, or just someone who has information to share, digital signage gives you the ability to engage the viewer with your message.

There are myriad variables to consider when creating good content. What works in one retailer, or waiting room, or on a billboard, will not work on screens of the same nature because the audience makeup is different each time. This creates havoc for providers who are trying to get the right content in the right place at the right time. But there are a few basic principles that can be understood and applied across any medium that will give the provider and/or end user great content, great impact, and a greater return on the investment.

Great content tells a story. The unique environments and audiences give creators the opportunity to tell more intimate stories with greater impact, focusing on key features of the subject that appeal to the viewer at that particular time and place, rather than trying to cover all the bases in a short message you may find on television at home (a good reason why “It’s not TV”). Because digital signage is a more dynamic way to communicate, providers can leverage the creative resources to tell a better story about their brand, or product, or service. For example, a cell-phone provider may be able to show live action of the cell-phones screen and interface (think of the iPhone commercials) as an advantage over other cell-phone manufacturers. This has tremendous impact at the point of sale, where the phones are on the shelf, where customers ready to buy. Great content creates competitive differentiation.

Great content can engage a viewer like no other type of communication. And with the growth of interactivity through touch screens and mobile devices, that engagement can become personal and inspirational. Brands, products, and services can now connect with customers and consumers at all points of interaction, from the internet at home to touch-screen kiosks in the store to mobile social media that allows users to define a brand or product in their eyes. The effort to change behaviors and create impact is tremendous when the customer becomes engaged with the message.

Great content makes money. In the case of retailing, relevant and compelling content will encourage a viewer to purchase a product. The revenue generated from more product sales in turn becomes a budget that retailers can spend on bigger and better digital signage applications. The technology of digital signage alone does not generate the revenue needed to purchase a network. The largest revenue generator for digital signage is the content and the amount of money someone will pay to put a message on your screen.

Here’s the catch: This is easier said than done. The research and strategy that goes into creating an engaging network can be extreme and often nebulous. The factors of audience demographics, environmental attributes, and advertising requirements all play very heavily on the composition and execution of great content. For example, creating content that runs longer than a person’s dwell time at the point of viewing will keep the viewer from getting the message because she has already moved on. Another example is sound. In a noisy environment, audio will not be effective in communicating a message, so the message should be entirely visual. Any aspect of the message in audio can and will be lost on the viewer because he cannot hear it.

However, the front-end work that goes into understanding the variables of compelling content can pay dividends in the end when the understanding of important features creates guidelines from which terrific content, and viewer engagement, can be achieved.

Content is that important.

The thing that I enjoy most about shows like DSE is connecting with industry contemporaries and those who I have established connections with via online communication platforms. Having the opportunity to meet face-to-face with industry friends I have made through this blog, Twitter, Linkedin, and other social media channels is something that I cherish. At DSE, it’s the people you meet and the conversations that you have which make the event unforgettable. I always welcome the opportunity to meet new folks and share interesting conversations with people who exude passion for digital signage, retail customer experience, emerging communication platforms, etc.

I shared conversations with a wealth of uber-smart individuals on topics such as location-based mobile services, real-time news, the future of digital out-of-home media, social media pollination across the enterprise, using digital technologies to enhance internal communications, digital signage as a brand/customer experience gateway, emerging mobile platforms, etc. It’s in these conversations that industry participants and I waxed analytical on digital signage’s role in our communications ecosystem and the technology’s advertising future. To those who I shared conversations with, thank you. To those who I didn’t get a chance to connect with, please feel free to reach out if you would like to talk (best way to reach me is via email: david.weinfeld@presetgroup.com). I am always happy to talk and help out in any way that I can.

Thoughts from the Show Floor

I don’t think that a single person who attended the show would argue that the technology on the event floor wasn’t impressive. As you entered the expo hall floor, it was like a treat for your eyes. Digital signs stretched as far as the eye could see. From thin screens to video walls and outdoor displays, the technical side of the industry was more than well represented. If you love digital signage (I assume that you have at least a passing interest in the technology if you’re reading this blog), your feelings about the environment would run parallel to my own.

The technology that powers the digital signage and digital out-of-home media industries was front and center on the show floor. While screens, media players, and interactive elements stretched across every square foot of the Las Vegas Convention Center, such a setup ran counter to the goal of educating newcomers and longtime attendees about digital signage and future industry developments. For anyone that was new to the digital signage industry, they likely left the show floor with more questions than answers.

An enormous focus was placed on digital signage technology at the detriment of featuring solutions that solve real business problems. The show floor lacked balance between the hardware/software side of the industry and the experiences that the technology powers. Too much emphasis was placed on the physical boundaries of the technology. Many missed the chance to feature digital signage as a gateway to expansive customer and brand experiences. The technology, and all of the bells and whistles, are great to look at it, but the sheen of these objects fade if they aren’t framed within the greater context of digital signage’s far reaching impact.

Many people I spoke with described the show floor as “cluttered” or “difficult to navigate.” For some, it felt like a summer camp reunion, drawing the conclusion based on a limited number of attendees outside of the digital signage and technology industries. If you got a nickel for every agency or brand rep. that was at the show, you would barely be able to afford a fast food combo meal.

One industry friend who is extremely knowledgeable on digital signage technology even admitted that he dreaded walking the show floor. This sentiment came from someone who loves digital out-of-home media. I can understand why he felt this way. For anyone who was new to digital signage, these end users were met with software companies all appearing to do the same thing (some claiming they could do more, others claiming best-in-class solutions, and none willing to admit that a potential customer would be better suited speaking to one of their competitors).

One of the few advertising agency reps. in attendance equated the expo to a “picks and shovels show.” He found the show lacking in relevance to his specific discipline. He commented that his agency colleagues don’t have anywhere near the same interest in technology as he does. They just want to know that it works.

A screen is a screen, but a true digital signage solution is an experience. This is an ethos that needs to be shared across the industry and, most importantly, carried throughout the Digital Signage Expo.

The people I was yakking with couldn’t figure out why, but it was pretty clear to me. The companies chose their thing. Their vertical. And then they went after it hard.

In a little more than a week the North American part of the industry will gather in Las Vegas for DSE, and prospective buyers will walk into the exhibit hall and be greeted by a sea of exhibits from companies that are all pitching pretty much the same thing. They will see countless booths and hear countless pitches about the nuances of why a particular company’s way of doing things is the cat’s pyjamas (always wanted to use that phrase …) but not a lot that distinguishes them.

Not that many companies at the show will set themselves up in a way that clearly tells prospects, “If you are looking for a solution that is laser-focused on doing this, or serving that, we’re your guys.” Almost all the pitches and positioning will be a riff on the right message, right time thing.

It’s all very general, and leaves the vendors engaged in an endless scrap over features, personalities and, what they really don’t want, price.

Then there are the other guys who are just quietly going about their business servicing a particular vertical category … and not a broad vertical like retail. I mean narrowed down to a sub-category of retail. Or maybe they just do campus. Or museums.

They got focused. They developed sector expertise and tailored their message and their product and service officer to a particular area. Instead of 300 software companies, maybe they’re competing with three on jobs. Or none.

There are companies in this industry who don’t show up at the trade shows. They don’t make a lot of noise. They just do their thing with their own narrowed list of targets. When they do trade shows, it is THE trade show in their vertical. Sometimes, they’re the only digital signage company there.

The people who run those companies figured out getting focused made more sense than trying to get noticed in the crowd.

If I am a guy looking for a solution, I am going to be a lot more engaged by someone who understands my business, and its dynamics and challenges,  than I am by someone else who may have more brand recognition and flashier material, but only a fleeting grasp of what I do and need.

People are going to walk up to booths at DSE in a few days and just flat ask salespeople, “What do you guys do?”

If all they’ve got to answer back with is some canned blah-blah-blah stuff with scale and reliable and cost-efficient lobbed in the patter, that’s a problem.

There are some big guys with big budgets coming into this sector now and they probably aren’t going away. But they’re just getting started and their offers are really undefined.

Pick what you’re really good at. Look at where the market opportunities are and what kinds of businesses are either recession-proofed and hopefully expanding. And look for those categories in which digital signage is a need to have, not a nice to have.

Get some focus, and you could flourish.

The show was great!

Not only did I enjoy countless engaging, vibrant conversations, I also came in contact with a wealth of exciting new technologies. The attendance was strong. Optimistic energy fueled the show’s atmosphere. You could tell that attendees recognized how important it is for them to integrate customer-facing technology into their environments.

I had to navigate large crowds throughout the day, especially as I walked through the Innovation Station, a collection of hand-picked retail solutions driving the future of the industry. Kudos need to be given to CRI for bringing together such a great, and diverse, array of solution providers.

The IBM booth (more like a control center) was picked with digital goodies and innovative retail solutions. Just like at the Innovation Station, I had to navigate crowds of engaged attendees to get from point A to point B. Within IBM’s “showcase,” I saw a range of technologies, including location aware mobile applications and in-store augmented reality displays. The company sees the writing on the wall, and knows that the world of bricks-and-mortar is undergoing an in-store digital revolution. IBM sees its deep involvement in various aspects of retailers’ operations as a clear foundation on which to build new media experiences.

NRF 2010 will be remembered for a number of different things, one of which is sure to be the number of tech giants showcasing new digital signage solutions. The show saw digital signage solutions from tech stalwarts like HP, Dell, Intel, Microsoft, and IBM (just to name a few). It is an exciting development for our industry to see the aforementioned “big boys” step into our pond. I’m not saying that they’re not going to stumble here and there along the way. As these companies acclimate themselves to the world of digital signage, they will learn from their mistakes and discover nuances of the market. Their depth of talent, experience, sizable R&D departments, and tech industry leverage is sure to drive DS forward. I see it as a ringing endorsement of the auspicious future that lies ahead for the digital signage marketplace.

With companies like Intel and Microsoft taking a major interest in digital signage, such activity is guaranteed to accelerate the growth of the industry. Not only do many of these DS newcomers want to grow their presence in the sector, they want to take leadership positions therein. We all know that such a thing is easier said than done, but I’m sure that some of the executives I met with are going to have a major impact on this industry. One such individual is Jose Avalos, the Director of Digital Signage at Intel.

Unless you were living under a rock, you heard about the multitouch, holographic intelligent digital signage concept that Intel featured at the show. Equipped with anonymous video analytics (facial recognition software from Cognovision) and an array of top-notch digital and technical features, the innovative solution captured the imagination of attendees. I must applaud Intel and Microsoft for recognizing that one must make a big splash when entering new markets to get people’s attention. Jose Avalos sees and understands the lasting place digital signage will have across the retail ecosystem. Speaking with Jose, even for just a few minutes, was illuminating. He spoke passionately about Intel’s approach to the industry and desire to deliver solutions that will enhance how we shop.

Looking around the show, you couldn’t help but feel the energy that circled the Javits Center floor. The time is upon us to grasp the ship carrying the future of retail. The vessel is filled with impassioned individuals who see the potential inherent in bringing real-time, efficient, and smart technology to the corner store and neighborhood shopping mall.

I welcomed connecting with professionals in the show’s Design Studio. Design houses and architects are definitely keen to the coming flood of technology at retail. I connected with RFID providers, audience analytics firms, customer loyalty companies, and automated retail companies (I love ZoomSystems). With everything I saw, and all of the people I spoke with, I can confidently say that the tide is rising. If you want to ride the wave of new retail engagements and experiences, you better jump on board.

The folks at VeriFone, who just acquired Clear Channel’s Taxi Media operations, are definitely thinking beyond the payment space. With VeriFone’s technical footprint across retail and a range of other industries, they are surely a company to watch as media begins to get further integrated into these solutions. It’s a natural progression to equip POS systems with small-form factor displays that enhance the retail environment.

While Intel’s partnership with Microsoft in developing a multi-touch retail solution has garnered the most press from the show, I was equally captivated by another solution from one of Intel’s partners at NRF. Mark my words that the company I mention next is one that will have a long, prosperous future in the digital signage industry (and beyond!).

YCD Multimedia displayed the robustness of the company’s software solution in driving a nine screen Samsung video wall (plus a tenth interactive screen) from a single player (powered by an Intel processor, of course). The video wall was capable of playing out 9 different channels of content, unique to each screen. I was blown away by the fact that the system was running from one media tower. The screen displayed 4K content, meaning 4X HD resolution, given that each display was running at its native 1080p resolution.

That by itself was impressive, but then Josh Kampel, YCD’s head of business development, took the covers of off the company’s most recent innovation – RAMP. An advertising management system that is as intuitive and beautiful as it is robust, RAMP bridges corporate and local network control, while supporting easy content creation, data management, playlist creation, and campaign scheduling. Their solution is a next step for the digital signage industry.

With everyone that I met (it was a pleasure), and all of the technology that I saw, going to NRF was like walking into FAO Schwartz for the first time as youngster. I feel this way every time I go to one of these shows. As geeky as this sounds, I love technology. I especially love how technology can enhance our lives, how we shop, how we interact, how we communicate, etc. What was great about my trip to NRF this year, is that the vast majority, if not everyone, whom I came in contact with shared that same passion for technology.

As the mobile web and smartphones approach mainstream adoption, we will see more robust uses of mobile technology in retail environments. The growth of the mobile application economy, spurred by the launch of the iPhone, has succeeded in bringing tools to market that make our daily lives easier (inside and outside of the home).

“We are at the cusp of this technology really driving a lot of activity during the shopping season,” said Stacy Janiak, United States retail practice leader at Deloitte. “It is both an opportunity and a challenge for a retailer, because you can have a consumer who can cross-shop your store with other bricks-and-mortar stores or online, all from the convenience of your aisle.”

Retailers need to embrace the mobile web and smartphone applications. Consumers are increasingly using applications from companies like ShopSavvy, RedLaser, and My Coupons to ensure that they are getting the best deals at retail. While it can be argued that applications like ShopSavvy and Red Laser, barcode readers for real-time price comparisons, hinder bricks-and-mortar retail, these consumer-based tools, in truth, challenge retailers to evolve. They push retailers to learn more about their customers, react more adeptly to changes in consumer demand, and enhance their shopper marketing efforts.

When a consumer pulls his iPhone from his pocket and scans the tag of a leather jacket to get price comparisons from nearby retailers and e-commerce sites, it creates a clear opportunity for the retailer whose store he’s in to rise to the challenge. Accepting the fact that consumers have product buying guides, price comparison tools, customer reviews, etc. at their fingertips, pushes retailers to adapt to a marketplace now dominated by empowered consumers.

Whether it be in the form of matching prices customers receive from mobile applications, delivering real-time mobile coupons, offering customer loyalty incentives, or providing value-added services at no cost, offline retailers must flex their marketing, customer service, and sales muscle to stay competitive.

If someone standing in one store scans a product with ShopSavvy, for example, a retailer down the street could deliver the shopper a coupon for the same item. A major retailer is already doing that in a few test cities, including Seattle, said Alexander Muse, co-founder of Big in Japan, the start-up that created ShopSavvy.

Other applications, including Yowza, use the GPS location information in cellphones to send shoppers coupons for stores within walking distance of where they’re standing. “This empowers consumers to make a smart decision,” Mr. Muse said. “Already, retailers are starting to figure out, ‘I need to be in this game.’ ”

There was a fantastic article in Friday’s New York Times that detailed the depths to which mobile applications are being utilized at retail during the holiday season. The piece is a must read. Not only do I recommend the article, but I implore you to read it.

Without getting into the full details of Brogan’s retail misadventure (a search for the Timberland Earthkeepers brand boot), his frustration stemmed from contact with a string of apathetic store associates who lacked knowledge of Timberland’s new line of boots.The negative aspect of his shopping experience was exacerbated by the fact that the Timberland store he visited had not yet received their first shipment of the company’s new Earthkeepers boots. This element of the experience grew exponentially worse once Brogan returned home and found the shoes in stock on Zappos.

In summing up the whole experience, Brogan wrote the following:

I guess, in thinking this all over a bit more, I’ve come to realize that there’s really very little reason to walk into a brick and mortar retail store for most products these days. I can research better on the web. I can get better opinions on the web. I can find better deals via the web. And I can actually order something that was advertised, when using a web channel.

What does that tell YOU about retail?

Chris Brogan’s large community of readers responded en masse. While a large number agreed with his criticism of Timberland (”Why couldn’t the guy working at the original Timberland store pull up their corporate website and order them for him?”), some felt remiss that Brogan didn’t offer actionable marketing or customer service solutions to improve face-to-face retail.

Shifting one’s behavior to only shopping online, is not the answer. I wholeheartedly agree that the majority of face-to-face retail experiences underwhelm when compared to the online alternative. That doesn’t mean, however, that bricks-and-mortar retail is relegated to a subservient position to its online counterpart; or that consumers must accept that most in-store experiences will leave them wanting more.

Bricks-and-mortar is not destined to become an irrelevant relic of the pre-digital age. If anything, deficiencies in bricks-and-mortar service create opportunities for change. I believe that we are headed toward a bricks-and-mortar retail revolution. The Web has fostered customer expectations that call for quick, efficient, and flexible service. With countless alternatives to shopping in stores filled with disenfranchised, apathetic associates, retailers cannot afford to let their bricks-and-mortar establishments become customer service graveyards.

E-commerce has changed the game for retail. Customers expect to find what they are looking for in an instant, receive recommendations based on recent purchases, and, ultimately, have the ability to shape their own shopping experience. Retailers need to take technologies from the Web and bring them into bricks-and-mortar. They need to equip associates with devices and technologies that enhance their product knowledge. Associates must have digital tools at the ready. They need to have detailed product information at their fingertips at all times. They must have the ability to pull up real-time inventory information, access product fact sheets with the push of a button, and offer store patrons customized assistance.

The days of unknowledgeable associates being the status quo are over. The lessons learned through e-commerce and web-based shopper analysis call for more robust in-store experiences. Just as e-commerce storefronts offer targeted shopping experiences based on consumer preferences so too must physical stores fluidly respond to the needs of different customers.

The solution isn’t to transition to online-only sales channels, but to demand that face-to-face retail fulfills the same needs that consumers have come to expect online. Bricks-and-mortar retail is far from being as efficient, technologically-advanced, or flexible as it could be, and should be. This is one of the reasons why digital signage and self-service technology are such exciting fields to be in. Empowered consumers require retail experiences that speak to their individual needs and desires.

“Where is the…?”
“Do you have…?”

Yet, the retailer has not executed digital signage that can answer these questions. The ideal place for this digital concierge is in the store’s “landing zone,” or the first 20 feet or so inside the doors. Some retailers prefer to keep this area free from a lot of noise and promotion as a way to allow the customer to decompress and transition from traveling to the store to the experience inside it.

I believe this is the very place where customers expect to be directed. Customers enter and orient themselves with the new surroundings. Those that are short on time do not walk to the back of the store and then ask, “Where is the…?” They would prefer to ask up front and get their shopping finished.

In February, 2009, Herb Sorensen wrote “Deconstructing the Shopping Trip (so far!).” Mr, Sorensen states that these questions are actually an effort by customers to break down barriers erected by the brands and retailers. The two questions he sees (closely related to the two above) are:

Where is the . . ?
Which one of these . . ?

“The first of these plagues the shopper when store layout does not match the shopper’s natural navigational practices and the second when it is unclear which of many options is the right one for the shopper.”

So why is it that retailers have yet to fully embrace this as an opportunity to assist the customer’s path to purchase?

The holiday shopping season is rarely the enjoyable treat we see played out by so many retailers in their holiday campaigns. Instead of jingle-bell laden happy music, fluffy snow, rosy cheeks, and beautiful store employees, we have bad weather, empty shelves, muzak, and employees who would rather hit the local tavern than help the umteenth customer find the batteries. This is a terrific mixture for stress.

This year will be another “make or break” season for some retailers, and they are pulling out all the stops to make sure they don’t push daisies next spring. One plan is not adding employee head count in the store, the part-time seasonal workers that come in to help with the customer traffic rush. This is an easy way to avoid costs.

Providing a solution to the most basic questions a customer has would solve two challenges: It would alleviate stress on the shopper to search and discover the item of choice was out of stock; and it would reduce the stress on an employee to help every single customer that walks through the door, instead focusing on customers that need detailed help. The ideal state finds the navigational interactive device tied to the local POS system to indicate whether an item is still in stock.

Interactive navigation is ideal in situations where customers can shop on their terms, and the holiday shopping season provides no better time to execute this type of digital interactivity.

Maybe that’s why the internet is so attractive for holiday shopping. You can search for something and find it without leaving your comfy chair as the fireplace crackles, the fluffy snow mounts outside your window, and your iPod rattles the ornaments with “Winter Wonderland.”

The new American Eagle store has an absolutely towering 25-storey wall of tight pixel LEDs rising from a corner off the landmark square, and wrapping around it. Other stores and media companies have also spent Lord knows how much making themselves noticed.

It’s all quite amazing, and has very little to do with digital signage as it plays out day to day, Yes, they are signs, and they are digital. But the comparison end pretty much there.

What these big boards tell us, though, is just how important it is to be big with visuals. Most of what’s deployed in the digital signage industry right now is, quite arguably, too small for its surroundings. A screen that eats a wall in someone’s main living area at home looks relatively tiny hanging from a high ceiling in a 100,000 square foot food barn. Unless a screen is down at eye level or nested with product, a big LCD or plasma in many settings struggles to get noticed.

The novelty factor of big flat panel monitors is long gone, so people aren’t looking at them because they are there.

So what do you do? Try other stuff.

In retail, and the other indoor spaces that are the mainstream of what we called digital signage, big LEDs don’t really work. Too costly, too bright, and while the image reproduction on the indoor versions can look pretty good from a distance, up close, the visuals look terrible. The LED bulbs are too far apart. They have a role, but a limited one.

Big projection screens present too many maintenance issues and physical challenges, and the visuals never look great in a bright room. Sunlight and ambient light are the enemies and may always be.

LCD and plasma walls that have screens stitched together look much better, but even the newest ones still have very noticeable seams between the screens, and are a lot of work to keep all looking the same. They have presence, but what gets put up tends to look compromised from the moment these walls turn on.

That’s why I was very intrigued about a new product being rolled out by Christie Digital, a company that has been in the projection business for many decades, but has now developed a product that takes the display business in a new direction.

I did some writing for the company in the lead-up to the launch of MicroTiles, so there is my conflict declared. But that’s where my interests end. I am writing about the technology now, because it deals effectively with the BIG thing.

The tiles have very bright LED light engines inside self-contained units that can stack and join in any number of shapes. So instead of a video wall always being a uniform wall, it can be as jagged as a bar chart tracking the stock market. It can wrap around door frames. It can run up support columns, or look like an LED ribbon board in a sports arena.

The difference is that the clarity and color reproduction are superior to LED and better even than the monster LCD and plasma stuff in rich guys’ home cinemas. The units will last for more than seven years at 24/7 usage. And they service fast and easily from the front, and are self-aware, meaning the Tiles talk to each other and calibrate on the fly. Where regular video walls get patchy from screen to screen, these tiles steadily compare notes and sync up.

And the seams are 1 mm. That’s it. Hairline.

Gorgeous stuff. A little pricey and meant for now for flagship stores and big-ticket venues. But over time, these units could be very commonplace.

The reason: They deal with all the issues and needs of BIG.

That is very good news for all of us. A lot of retailers are not yet doing digital signage because what they have seen in store has large been uninspiring and lacking true impact. Ad sales on many networks struggle because the screens they install doesn’t get the notice numbers they need.

But when display technology can get fitted into these sorts of environments and both dominate and fit the space, that really is BIG.

Thanks to the current shift in content creation, distribution, and consumption, emerging media companies stand to reap the greatest gain by turning old business models on their heads. It’s important to remember; however, that there are elements of the old guard that are worth preserving and building from.

I’m not here to echo the death of newspapers or other forms of traditional media. I think we can all agree that newspapers, magazines, TV, etc. aren’t going anywhere. As we enter the age of real-time news and constant communication, they may not look the same, behave the same, be distributed in the same manner, or rely on their current business models; but it’s illogical to think that pillars of the media industry will just vanish. Just as companies in a vast array of industries have had to adapt in order to stay relevant and survive, so too must traditional media companies reimagine themselves in a world of universal publishers and empowered consumers.

In the same way that traditional media companies must expand beyond their once safe silos of operations, digital OOH networks must not fall into the trap of fencing themselves off from other media outlets and content models. Rather than solely focusing on the DOOH platform, which can bring stars to they eyes of the most seasoned entrepreneur, these organzations must embrace the opportunity to become 360 degree media companies.

The disclaimer here is that I’m not promoting a DOOH media company launch a radio network or newspaper; or create business lines that are incongruent with the organzation as a whole. But, what about launching a podcast series or a digital newsletter? For niche place-based networks in doctors offices and veterinary clinics, distributing content through media platforms like these can serve to spread the reach of the network’s brand. Cross-channel distribution can increase a DOOH network’s status in its respective vertical, and create opportunities for its content to be discovered by a broader audience.

The financial barriers that once restricted a new media company’s ability to reach a mass audience are now gone. You don’t need radio towers, satellites, or large infrastructures for distribution. A blogger, an upstart online magazine, or DOOH media network all have the opportunity to become pillars of our media future. To do so, they need to be ready to adapt and expand at a moment’s notice.